Forbidden Broadway is an Off-Broadway revue parodying musical theatre, particularly Broadway musicals. It was conceived, written and directed by Gerard Alessandrini.

Before a grade-school backdrop depicting heathery hills, a pair of confused theatre-goers struggle with an outdated map of Broadway while an offstage chorus sings, "Brink of doom, Brink of do-om," and before you can say "Come ye to the spoof," the cast of Forbidden Broadway: Alive and Kicking is promising that, "Just like Jesus and Judy Garland, we're resurrected again."

1. Prologue and Forbidden Broadway: Alive And Kicking (Natalie, Scott, Jenny, Marcus) 3:56
2. Livin' Evita Loca (Jenny & Marcus (with Natalie & Scott)) 3:57
3. Matthew Broderick & Kelli O'hara Do Nice Work (Marcus & Natalie (with Scott & Jenny)) 4:03
4. Annie/Granny (Jenny (with Natalie, Scott & Marcus)) 1:28
5. Once Is Enough (Scott & Jenny (with Natalie & Marcus)) 6:42
6. Sondheim And Bernadette (Marcus & Jenny) 3:33
7. Rock Of Ages (Nascar Shows) (Scott & Natalie (with Jenny & Marcus)) 2:26
8. Sutton Foster In Anything Goes (Jenny (with Scott & Marcus)) 2:34
9. Catherine-Zeta Jones On The Tony Awards (Natalie (with Marcus, Jenny, Scott)) 3:13
10. Newsies (Jenny & Marcus (as Ghost Girl & Harvey Fierstein) & Scott (as Jeremy Jordan) & cast) 5:47
11. Julie Taymor & Bono In Spider-Man (Natalie & Scott (with Jenny & Marcus)) 2:48
12. Porgy & Mess Segment (Natalie & Scott (with Jenny & Marcus)) 5:32
13. Smashed (Jenny & Natalie) 3:17
14. Mandy & Patti (Marcus & Jenny) 5:04
15. Judy Garland At The End Of The Rainbow (Jenny) 3:22
16. The Book Of Morons (Scott & Marcus) 3:57
17. Finale (Natalie, Scott, Jenny, Marcus) 0:45
18. On Our Way Encore (Natalie, Scott, Jenny, Marcus) 1:05
Total Album Time: 63:29